Well, I originally wrote this article a while after I’d finished preparing the final comic update in a webcomic mini series that I’ll be posting here in mid-late January. I’m mentioning this because it’s relevant to the topic of this article, namely knowing which comic ideas to use.
Although it’s common to feel uninspired when making a webcomic, sometimes you can find yourself having the opposite problem – you’ve got too many ideas. Normally, this isn’t a problem (in fact, it’s a good thing). But, it can cause problems if you limit yourself to a certain number of comic updates and/or if the many ideas you’ve got aren’t that good.
I mostly had the latter problem with the final update of this mini series. Although I’d vaguely planned the whole thing, when it came to making the final update, I realised that my original plan for it wasn’t very good. It was more of a placeholder plan, a plan that was there if I couldn’t come up with a better idea by the time that I’d made the first five comic updates. And on the night before I made the final comic, I realised that I couldn’t come up with a better idea.
So, what did I do? Well, here are two of the things I considered when making my decision about the comic:
1) Themes: One of the best ways to come up with comic ideas is to have a common theme that you can use for a group of comics. If your comics revolve around a particular theme, then at least you’ve got something to start with when it comes to thinking of comic ideas.
Although I don’t always remember to come up with a theme, this upcoming mini series had the theme of “introspection and philosophy”. As soon as I remembered this, I realised why both my placeholder idea and another idea I’d come up with wouldn’t work.
They were basically political cartoons. The rest of the mini series had been fairly apolitical, so the ideas weren’t a good fit. Yes, it was easy to make cynical comics about politics and, yes, I had two pre-made ideas. But, this wasn’t what this mini series was about. So, even though I was still feeling uninspired, I realised that I had to find a new idea. And it had to be about “introspection and philosophy”.
Yes, it took me a while to find a good enough comic idea, but remembering the theme of the comic that I was making helped me to focus on making a better comic that actually fit in with the rest of the comics that I was making.
So, if you’re unsure of which comic idea to use, then look at the general themes etc.. of your webcomic and go with the idea that fits into those things the most.
2) Fun: This one is fairly self-explanatory. Go with the comic idea that seems like it will be the most fun to make. Generally, this will make you feel more motivated and will probably result in a better comic update.
For example, one of the things that I’d focused on with this upcoming mini series was paying more attention to the artwork. Since I had a bit more time to make comics, I wanted them to look good. I wanted to be able to do something a bit more creative with the art.
So, I knew that whatever idea I used had to be one that allowed me to show off artistically- because it’s fun to do this. And, as you can see from this preview, the art is a little bit more sophisticated than usual:
So, ask yourself “which part of my webcomic do I enjoy the most? Art? Writing? Humour? Characterisation?”. When you’ve got your answer, go with the idea that allows you to do that the most.
Anyway, I hope that this was useful 🙂